Tweet

MODERN VS. TRADITIONAL ASTROLOGY DEBATE

I recently participated in a debate on the topic of modern versus traditional astrology, with astrologer Eric Meyers representing the modern approach, while I represented the traditional approach.

As part of the debate each of us made opening statements in defense of our respective traditions. What I have below is the position statement that I wrote in defense of traditional astrology.

The debate itself lasted for 2 hours, and you can download the full recording of it through The Astrology Podcast:Modern vs. Traditional Astrology Debate.

 

Traditional Astrology: Opening Statement

For the purpose of this debate I will define “traditional astrology” as a collection of astrological doctrines that coalesced into a system for studying fate somewhere around the 1st century BCE in Alexandria, Egypt, and was practiced, refined, and expanded until the late 17th century. While there were a number of different traditions and variations in both the practice and conceptualization of astrology during this period, there was an underlying continuity in the main outlines of the approach. Hellenistic astrology in particular represented a synthesis of the scientific, cultural, and spiritual trends of the Mesopotamian, Egyptian, and Greco-Roman traditions. The syncretic form of astrology that was produced by these cultures was practiced within both a practical as well as a spiritual context, equally giving room to both spheres of life.

In the 17th century astrology fell out of favor culturally and intellectually due to a variety of different reasons. It was not revived again until the late 19th and early 20th century, at which point it was largely taken up by proponents of spiritualism and Theosophy. There were deliberate attempts at this point to simplify the technical apparatus of astrology in order to make it easier to learn and disseminate, and these efforts resulted in a decline of the system from a technical standpoint compared to what had been practiced before. At the same time changes in education which made it so that Greek and Latin were no longer taught in primary schools made it so that the texts of the earlier tradition were inaccessible to modern readers, thus further isolating them from the tradition.

This lack of familiarity with the actual practice of traditional astrology made it an easy scapegoat, and reformers have continually used it as a sort of bogyman in order to justify their own further modifications of the few fragments of the system that they inherited. While those in the scientific community could genuinely say that they were standing on the shoulders of giants when making some of the greatest scientific discoveries of the 20th century, modern astrologers could not share the same sentiment, as they only stood on the ashes of the 2000 year tradition of astrology that existed prior to their time.

The Uranus-Neptune conjunction in the early 90s coincided with a revival of traditional forms of astrology in the west, as astrologers began setting up translation projects and recovering the primary source texts of the Hellenistic, Indian, Medieval, and Renaissance traditions. During this period of recovery astrologers found many useful techniques that complemented and enhanced concepts that were already in use in modern times, such as the distinction between day and night charts known as sect, and they also found some powerful timing techniques that could do things that astrologers didn’t even know were possible, such as Zodiacal Releasing and the time-lord systems. The end result of the revival of traditional astrology is that astrologers are once again rebuilding a system of astrology that is capable of making specific statements about the concrete external circumstances of a person’s life with surprising accuracy. However, traditional astrologers do not simply focus on external events, but they draw on their historical connection with many different religious, spiritual, and mystery traditions in order to provide a deeper spiritual and philosophical context for astrology as well – one that is rooted in the genuine philosophies of the western exoteric and esoteric tradition, rather than just the more recent appropriations of some pieces of those traditions by the New Age movement. This ability to address both external circumstances as well as internal dispositions results in an astrology that is more holistic than an astrology that is only capable of dealing with the psyche.

From a technical standpoint traditional astrology is more oriented towards the subjective experience of the individual, and many of the techniques are designed in order to be able to explain both how the native will experience events personally, as well as what the broader meaning and purpose of those events are in their life. While modern astrologers reject distinctions such as benefic and malefic in order to attempt to empower their clients, traditional astrologers utilize these distinctions as necessary tools in giving the proper level of respect and credence to the wide spectrum of human experience, which includes extremes of both positive and negative, as well as many shades of grey in between. Far from being too simplistic or black and white, traditional astrology employs more technical distinctions and nuances than modern astrology, which allows it to more accurately describe the full range of possible manifestations of a specific chart placement.

The purpose of the revival of traditional astrology is not to go back to the past and simply to stay there, but rather the purpose is to reconnect us with what was a continuous living tradition of knowledge, wisdom, and experience that was passed down from generation to generation until the link was severed a few centuries ago. The revival of the ancient traditions and their subsequent synthesis with whatever the prevailing modern paradigm is at the time is a reoccurring theme in the history of astrology in the wake of every Uranus-Neptune conjunction going back over 2000 years. In my opinion the syncretic approach that this represents is a far better alternative to astrological fundamentalism of any sort, either of the old or of the new.

Facebbok Comments

Comments

Be the first to comment

Leave your comment


Categories

I am very grateful to God that I met Aakash sir who tought me the Astrology science and skills so precisely with an ease to learn. He also helped with my Kundli and gave me his expert advise wen I was at a down stage of life . He is an expert mathematician and great programmer in computer softwares . I wish him all the very in life with success ahead.
Rating: 5 Daljeet Singh
Nice
Rating: 5 Amandeep Singh
I had a consultation with astrologer Mr.Akashdeep. no words to explain my happiness, accurate reading. I have been in distress, in a negative mindset, or confused. I very much appreciate all the genuine care, help, and hope given by Mr. Akashdeep. He is highly recommended and more than qualified with the vast knowledge of astrology that he possesses
Rating: 5 Deepak Gupta
First of all I would like to say thanks to my brother sunil Bhardwaj jinhone mujhe Akash bhaiya ka Refrence Diya best part of this Akash bhaiya is very good astrology I came to know Akash bhaiya since 1 year he always give good remedies and it’s works 100% he always support me help me whenever I need any help I called him & message he always replied me thank you so much bhaiya you will get more success in your life jaise aap bina reason ke sabki help karte ho god aapki bhi waise he help kare go
Rating: 5 Neha Bhardwaj
Rating: 5 Kusum
Akash Sir is very good in programming and also teach us astrology very well. I am happy to have teacher like him
Rating: 5 Mamta Goel
Rating: 5 Chirag
I know the Akashdeep sir by more than 3 years I was the student of astrology. He has good and deep knowledge of astrology and when he teachings their students, no one wants to stop him, as a student I learnt many new things and aspects. Pranaam Guruji...
Rating: 5 Gopal Krishan
Akash sir is my go-to-person for any life issues or problems. He has guided me through multiple situations and also given support throughout, since the time i know him. He is extremely knowledgeable and provides such an accurate picture that I am mind-blown so many times. I am really grateful- Akash Sir
Rating: 5 Neha
Having Good Knowledge, Discussed all the possibility regarding Kundli of my son. Thank You
Rating: 5 Kamal Kumar Kanodia
He is good & experienced astrologer. He gave proper time to listen our problems. His remedies are very effective. He has deep knowledge in astrology. My best wishes to him.
Rating: 5 Neeraj Trikha
Aakash sir is a very nice person and always ready to help others. He is a very knowledgeable person and a very good teacher.
Rating: 5 Babita Sharma
Mr. Akash sir is my teacher and a very simple person with a lot of knowledge in astrology I remember he teaches us about retrograde planets and that lecture was one of the best class. Thankyou Sir
Rating: 5 RAVINDER SONI
I was introduced to Akash ji by one of my colleagues in 2008. Since then Akash has been an excellent troubleshooter, a mentor, a guide and a wonderful friend to me and my family. He has a deep knowledge of Astrological science, a very logical analyst and always ready to help people and guide them. May he attain the epitome of his pursuit and passion in Astrology. A great human being and may he always stay blessed to help the humanity more and more.
Rating: 5 Hariharan
Very helpful and correct predictions .... gives a lot of time ... he is a very approachable person and the remedies he gives works like a charm we can contact him at any time if the day he makes sure he is available for all the people in need of his consultation
Rating: 5 Ashi
I have been in contact with Akash bhaiya for years now. Best part about him is the positivity with which he looks at every situation. His predictions are very accurate and the puja that he suggests are very helpful. He has always been there to help us. Along with remedies he brings lot of positivity in the situation. Really thankful for him.
Rating: 5 Ayush saxena
Very good and accurate predictions ....Gives a lot of time and tries to help as much as he can ... Tells the remedies fir all the problems
Rating: 5 Atul Saxena
Rating: 5 Anil Kumar Sharma
Rating: 5 Amar
Very helpful...apt...all the readings and suggestions remedies worked wonders for me...he's like a god for me, it was a difficult situation, but he was always there to support on call and whatsapp, wheneevr I wanted to consult He is the one person I was looking for who could help me, had consulted others as well, but trust me he is the one who can be a solution to all your concerns Om namah shivay.
Rating: 5 Kiran malik
A gem of a person. Approachable and available. Gives consultation like a family member.
Rating: 5 Ashutosh Agrawal
Really grateful to Akash Ji for his accurate predictions and Pooja service. My family and I have known him for last 5 years and he has been a great healer who has been helping us around mentally and astrologically. I man whom I can trust for his knowledge and genuine approach and therefore I wish that this review will be helpful for people looking for the best astrological results.
Rating: 5 Aditya Sharma
I have been consulting Akash sir for almost 5years. His predictions have been quite accurate. Recommended couple of friends too and they were also satisfied. Communicates in a simple way which people can easily understand.
Rating: 5 Bharat Garg
Akash sir jas deep knowledge of astrology..I always consult him ..His predictions aare always correct. Moreover he is good human being who always help everyone
Rating: 5 Monika
I Know Akash Ji for last 15 years. Whenever me or my family member come across with any problem or issue, we go to Akash ji for solution. Everytime, we get the right answer and right direction. Thanks Akash Ji!!!
Rating: 5 Praveen Pratap Singh
Practical ,futuristic and helpful astrology advise.
Rating: 5 Anu
Akash Sir is a Great Mentor, Astrologer. I have consult with him around 7-8 times. Always he gave me bestest solution. Thanks a lot Akash Sir.
Rating: 5 Deepesh Goyal
Akash ji ko main lagbahg 14 saal se jaanta hun.
Rating: 5 Praveen Pratap Singh
Shri Akashji helped us during a time of distress. He accurately provided us with solutions and advised and guided us. He not only provides Astrological details but also provided councelling. He has continued his support and advice ever since. I strongly recommend Shri Akashji.
Rating: 5 Rajwinder Singh
The predictions were accurate and was an interactive session.
Rating: 5 Rajeev
Rating: 4 Lovely Sharma
I have consulted Akash Bhaiya regarding my problem and I am glad he listens to each and everything so patiently and makes me understand the solution too..he has good communication skills and solutions he gave worked for me...he is a good astrologer
Rating: 5 Kairvee Bindal
This is awesome site. Thanks to provide knowledge about our religion.
Rating: 5 Amita Srivastava
Rating: 5 Pradeep Kumar
Best Astrologer I have known. He predicted so many things which came true. best i have known and a great person. Ph No 9212015029
Rating: 5 Tarrot Queen Meenu Sharmma
As per my interactions with Akash bhaiya, I have found him to be a blessed astrologer, extremely talented technically and more than that a great human being. I have known in him for more than a decade (10+ years) now. The best way is that you can disucss astrology very logically with him. He tell you the reason and potential solutions. He is very transparent and all those who have not tried taking his consultancy services, pl go with faith and belief. I'm sure, you will get best solution.
Rating: 5 Aditya Jain
Excellent, Always very helpful
Rating: 3 Rahul
Akash is not just an astrologer but a complete package of mentorship comprising solution, counseling and advice on all aspects of life. I always recommend him to others."
Rating: 5 Tarang Sharma
Akash Ji is the go to person for me no matter how happy or not happy I am. Extremely generous, as he listens to you patiently and gives suggestions according to the life stage you are in. My parents and I both always look up to him for consultation. His deep astrology knowledge and expertise helps us find our way forward in life.
Rating: 5 Himanshu Gupta
Excellent, Always very helpful
Rating: 5 Rahul
Akash sir is a good astrologer with deep knowledge..I always consult him as his predictions are always correct..But what make him more special is that he is a very good human being who always ready to help everyone
Rating: 5 Monika
Amazing interaction with Akash ji. He's very knowledgeable and friendly to talk to. I found him very polite and down to earth. Would like to consult him regularly and follow his advice. Thank you so much.
Rating: 5 Suruchi
Aakash Sharma is a successful software Engr aswell as good Astrologer.And above all he is a good human being and valued citizen. His pridictions are correct most of time. I love his vedic gyan articles. It helps me to know our vedic values. God bless you Akash.
Rating: 5 Sunita sharma
Akash Sir is very nice person. He is so down to earth. He listens to the problem very carefully and gives a solution for each. Thanks
Rating: 5 Ankita Srivastava
Akash Bhaiya is Good Programmer as well as good Astrologer too...Giving his Concerns to our culture and astro... Thanks for these amazing Content
Rating: 5 Adarsh Tomar
Fabulous content
Rating: 5 Payal
I love this site very much especially that Mohenjodaro one
Rating: 5 Nishchay Chaurasia
A wonderful person with simple remedies and advice .
Rating: 5 Anand Raman
I have been consulting Akash Bhaiya for more than 5 years. Every time I got satisfied and authentic solutions of my queries. He always address my problem and give considerable time to resolve it. He is a very generous person with excellent communication skill and have deep knowledge of Astrology.
Rating: 5 Seema Jain
Thanks for providing such information. It's really a nice step to retain our culture.
Rating: 5 Ankita
I have been consulting Sir since almost 4 years now. It has always been accurate for me. His ways of explaining are accurate and logical that actually correlates to reality. Thanks to all the guidance.
Rating: 5 Manas
Nice good
Rating: 4 Rohit vedi
Rating: 5 Johny
Ur site is very useful to me .
Rating: 4 Ritu porwal
Nice person with incredible knowledge on astrology. Truly impressed.
Rating: 5 Ravi
nice
Rating: 4 ashu
I never used to believe in predictions and astrology, but after Akash's prediction and genuine remedies of problems I started believing. Now I seek for his prediction whenever I 'm in dilemma or in problems.
Rating: 5 Amita Singh
Akash helped me many times through his predictions n remedies, awesome astrologer, but most importantly awesome person.
Rating: 5 Shivangi
Rating: 5 Abhishek
Best astrologer
Rating: 5 Abhishek
good and precise Information ..
Rating: 5 PraVeen Pratap singh
Akash is great astrologer that I have seen ever. His prediction is incredible. Apart from astrology, he is a great solution provider and a skilled engineer.
Rating: 5 Amita
Wonderful Astrologer with nice and precise knowledge on astrology.
Rating: 5 satyan
Excellent consultant...Highly Recommended.
Rating: 5 Amandeep
akash is one of the best astrologers i have seen till date... keep it up good work :-)
Rating: 5 shivam
Rating: 5 Arun
Akash as an astrologer is excellent. The way he understand the problem and provide the solution is incredible. Highly Recommended. Thanks Akash!!!
Rating: 5 Raj
Rating: 5 Nitin Raghuvanshi
Akash is the best astrologer i have seen
Rating: 5 Nitin
How would you rate Akash
Rating Criteria: 1 as Lowest and 5 as Best
Total Reviews : 69 Average rating : 4.91